I felt Andy toying with my hair. “I saw you eyeing my cock. You’re curious, aren’t you? You want to see it.”

I looked away from Andy, feeling guilty. He had definitely satisfied me, all he had done had been more than fantastic, but it was true that I couldn’t help myself... I had looked. I did want to see what it looked like. I wanted to touch it…

Andy giggled. “You absolutely can, in fact, I want you to! I want a lot more than that, actually. Playing with you has made me quite hot under the proverbial collar, (Y/N). And I’m not exactly keen on getting blue balls. What I’d like to offer you is one, final deal.”

Andy turned my head so I was looking at his radiant smile. His eyes were like the most stunning, iridescent jewels I had ever seen! “Thanks, babe, but I want you to focus for a sec, or this won’t count. I want your soul. If you give me your soul, I won’t just let you play with my dick, I will fuck you so hard-“

As Andy talked, I blinked, then shook my head. It was like moving underwater, but I forced the words out. “No! No way!”

Andy looked totally stunned. His perfect eyebrows rose high on his brow and his flawless mouth fell open, aghast. “No?”

Again, I forced myself to shake my head. Andy had taken more than enough! No one was taking my soul for a shag, not even Andy fucking Biersack!

Andy looked pained. “But baby, I actually want you! Don’t you want me? This isn’t fair-“

I rolled my eyes. “It’s plenty fair! You just took twenty years of my life! And you want my soul, just for a dicking? Like I can’t get laid elsewhere, you cocky-“

Andy knelt back and up on the bed, looking shocked, as though I had slapped him. His brows furrowed suddenly incredibly deeply. I watched, fascinated, as horns sprouted out of his head, and smoke billowed from his nostrils. “-I want you, woman, for my pleasure! Don’t you want to know what it feels like, to be fucked like a beast by the King of Desire and Lust himself? I ache to bury myself-“

Again, something about growing horns seemed a bit off from the norm, no matter how beautiful his blue eyes were. I pointed at him as I made up my mind. “-You can’t have my soul, Andy, and that’s final!” As an afterthought, to be less of a bitch, I added, “but you are totally hot.”

Andy roared, and fire shot out of his mouth, into the darkness. Some instinct of mine, distant but persistent, told me that fire-breathing was also very unusual.

I sat up and reached for my clothes, but felt Andy’s hand (were those claws?) closing on my wrist. “Wait, baby, wait!”

Impatient, I turned to face Andy. “What will it take? What can I do, so that you would lie with me, willingly, for pleasure?” Strange…I could have sworn Andy had horns a minute ago. Where had they gone?

Something, deep within, some gut feeling, told me to close my eyes as I contemplated the question. I went with it. The moment I did, I knew the answer. “If you return to me everything you’ve taken, you have a deal.”

I kept my eyes closed, but heard Andy’s sharp intake of breath. “You are sharp as a fucking tack. I’m shocked to know you haven’t dealt with me before. Lucky for you, I’m randy as a fucking buck, (Y/N). So I’ll make you a counter-offer. I will return to you all of your years, your skin, and your nails. But I want to keep the hair you traded me for myself, to remember you by. What do you say?”

Again, I thought quickly. “I’m on birth control, but-“

Andy laughed. “-You have a powerful mind, indeed. I can only impregnate the women who sell me their souls. And I don’t carry diseases of the flesh. No demon babies for you, (Y/N), at least, not yet. Do we have a deal?”

I opened my eyes. “Yes. I’ll have sex with you if you give me back everything except my hair.” I extended my hand, and Andy shook it. I felt a strange tingling, and found my nails and skin had returned by the time he let my hand go.

I watched, mesmerized, as Andy removed his pants. He was already hard, and precum stained his black briefs. He had such long legs! And… was that a tail I saw? “Don’t worry about that, babe.”

And then, like a dream, Andy was kissing me, and I let my hand seek out his length. When I found it, I felt a burst of adrenaline and elation. It felt perfect. Just palming it through his briefs, I could tell it was deliciously hard, long, and thick. I felt a yawning need to be fucked in my deepest core ignite, flashing through me like a bomb.

Eager, I broke away from Andy’s kiss so I could see it, at last! I was so curious! I pulled his briefs down and wasn’t disappointed in the least at what lobbed free of its confines. Holy shit!

Andy chuckled. “Holy nuthin’, sugar.”

Huh? I wrapped a hand around it, or, well, most of the way around it. I gave it a few strokes, eliciting a groan from Andy. “I don’t suppose I could talk you into riding me, could I? You have such beautiful tits and I’d enjoy the view-“

The compliment made me blush; it was unexpected. “-Ok. Lay down, then.” I watched Andy pull his briefs the rest of the way off, then lay back. I was already soaking wet from everything we’d done earlier. Good thing, too, with a dick like that!

Nervous, I straddled Andy’s hips. I felt Andy slick the head of his cock with my fluids, then hold himself in place, and he nodded. When I lowered myself down on Andy’s shaft, I couldn’t keep my eyes open, it was exquisite!

I could feel myself being spread wide open and apart, even in the deepest parts of me. While even holding still was profoundly erotic, my body instinctively knew what to do with the carnal intruder. Slowly, at first, I leaned forward, then drove my hips back against Andy’s pelvis, sinking him in even further. I could feel my own crude lust, voluminous from all we had done, easing the passage of his rock-hard phallus, seeping out around our joining.

Andy groaned, closing his gorgeous eyes. “Your cunt is finer than any demonic concubine’s! Milk me of my semen with your muscular walls, they are hot as hellfire, woman!”

His filthy talk turned me on, and I started moving faster. Andy gripped my ass with one hand, and brought one of my breasts to his mouth with the other. He started sucking and biting in between groans, his expression dazed.

I loved that I could have so much power over him! I loved that I could make him feel so good! I loved that I could make myself feel so good with him!

With each thrust, Andy would lift his hips to meet me, deepening the penetration. I could feel my nerves being prodded and poked, in places that had never been touched, now in ecstasy. Again and again, stroked, provoked, tantalized, so deep in my core.

My clit was swollen and rubbed easily against Andy’s pubic mound as I leaned forward, adding a heightened intensity. He moved to grab both of my hips just as I felt myself begin to let go. I caught his glittery gaze as I felt the crescendo approaching, he was frantically thrusting up into me, it felt incredible! “Your cunt is perfection! You want my seed?”

Euphoria blasted through my mind and body, short-circuiting all but my most primal functions. “Yes!” I screamed hoarsely as orgasm gripped me.

I was shocked to feel an eruption inside me, as Andy ejaculated the most massive load anyone could have imagined, still thrusting upwards and grunting. It seeped out from between us as I collapsed on top of him, completely satiated.

---

What seemed like hours later, I came to. I looked around, and saw Andy, completely dressed, sitting nearby, on his stool. Feeling self-conscious, I reached for the sheet to cover myself.

“There’s no need for that, sweetie, take your time. Really, no rush.” I glanced at Andy, and to my surprise, he blushed and looked away first.

“I admit I underestimated you, and by far. For that, I apologize. I need to get going, but whenever you’re ready, there’s the door.” Andy pointed, the dark mist cleared, and a door appeared, with a clearly marked exit sign.

Andy got off his stool and approached me. “I hope we meet again some day, (Y/N). Until next time?” Andy took my hand and lightly kissed it before disappearing into thin air. Something about that struck me, again, as odd, but I wasn’t sure why.

After a moment, I got dressed and gathered my things. The moment I stepped through the door, everything grew suddenly lighter! I turned around to get my bearings, and saw Yanni and Andy behind me! Andy winked at me and waved before turning to the next person in line for the meet and greet.

As I walked to the end of the line for entry into the concert later on, I couldn’t help but think how something in my gut told me there was something strange about Andy Biersack. I just couldn’t quite put my finger on it… Hey, was I missing some hair?

Notes