Hallie's POV:
"I love you."
"No.. I love you."
Andy pokes my nose and we giggle. I pull him into a long kiss, climbing on top of him. Our body heat the only thing keeping us warm since the sheets are piled at the foot of the bed. I look into Andy's eyes and suddenly burst into a fit of giggles, Andy does too.
"Hallie, I want you to know," Andy glances at the clock and back at me. It's 11:57. He pauses and watches anxiously as the clock turns from 7 to 8. Then from 8 to 9. Andy pulls the covers over us and roll over so we are facing each other sideways.
"Hallie, one minute and I'll tell you." He whispers and kisses me passionately. The door flies open and the lights turn on. They turn off again and the door slams shut.
"Holy shit! Andy? Who just caught us?" I ask nervously. The once anxious and loving look in his eyes is replaced by panic. "I-I don't know." He stutters. I lean over and place my lips back on his, just trying to calm him down. Andy kisses back but says, "hallie, we have to go out there and deal with this. At least I have to."
I sigh and let go of him. Andy grabs a pair of boxers and basketball shorts for himself nod tosses a large shirt to me. I put it on quickly and follow Andy to the door. He kisses me quickly before opening the door. I stay behind so that I'd it's Lola, she won't kill me.
"Andy! You bastard!"
Oh. It's ashley.

Andy's POV

"Ashley. I-"
He glares at me, "explain yourself!"
"Huh?"
"Tell me who that was and why the hell you were in there fucking someone who isn't Lola!"
"Uh. Oh... I am kinda in love with the other person.. And Lola.."
A muffled, "holy shit!" Comes from inside my room. I wanted to tell her that not ashley.
"But why are you cheating on Lola?"
"I just told you! I'm in love with two people!"
"Who is the other person." Ashley looks at me angrily.
"That doesn't matter."
"Who." I back up against my door and cross my arms, "it's none of your concern."
"Andy. I swear to god I will get past you if you don't tell me."
I turn to the door and whisper to hallie through it, "he won't hurt you baby. I'm not going to let him through. Alright?"
"Ok." Hallie Whispers back nervously.
In the middle of our conversation ashley had come up behind me and pushed me away from the door. He flings it open before I can object and gasps at hallie who is standing near the bed with a worried look plastered on her face.
"Ashley. You ruined our perfect night." I blurt. It was perfect- well except for this. His mouth is hung open at the sight of my room, clothes flung all over, a discarded condom in the trash.
He glances at Hallie, then to me. "You. You are 15." He points to hallie and then back to me, "that's sick. Just disgusting!" "Ashley. Leave." I say angrily.
He grumbles, "pedophile." And shakes his head.
"Don't tell Lola, please!" Hallie asks from where she's standing, "I don't want her mad at Andy."
Not her, me?
"I won't." He sighs, turning to me, "But Andy, you need to choose. Because you shouldn't cheat on your girlfriend. And just this is gross."
He walks out of the apartment, slamming the door shut behind him.
"Uh... Should we just.. Sleep then?" She asks. I nod and lay down in bed again with her. I try to cuddle with her but she moves away, still wearing the tshirt.
"Hallie? Do you want to cuddle?" I ask worried. She doesn't respond, now laying with her back to me. "Hallie, I'm sorry about that. Is there anyway I could make it up to you?" I scoot closer to her and stroke her cheek. She sighs and ignores me again. I come behind her and just lay down, wrapping my arms around her waist loosely and basically spooning.
She shifts away from me a bit more and whispers, "Andy, we can't do this anymore. Lola will never find out and you guys can date happily without me in the way of anything. I am saying this now and I'm not giving in to you again. Don't try to seduce me again ok? You love Lola."
A tear falls from her eyes, I reach to wipe it away but she stops me, grabbing my hand and holding on tight.
"Not me Andy." She whispers. "Remember, your words: Conscience begs for you to do what's right. Andy I'm doing what's right."
I was 17 hallie! I didn't know this would happen then!
Should I tell her, should I tell her that I love her? Or should I just forget about hallie and be happy with her sister. This should be easy. I should just be able to say that I want Lola, and only Lola.
Somehow I can't bring myself too do it.

Notes

Hmm?
I lost about 4 subscribers since I brought in the hallie thing. I get that a lot of you don't like it, I'm sorry. I think you'll like what happens in a few chapters though. But thanks to you guys who are still reading!
I posted my other story.. Somehow it has 4 subscribers and 0 reads? It's Can you see me? And I promise it is probably a lot less offensive or sexual than this. Please check it out?
-C