I Dare You

*Janice's POV*

"Do you think they had sex?," I asked Mikey as we got up for school.

"Come on Janice, this is Aph we're talking about. She's one of the most innocent person I've ever meet!," he laughed. How can she not have sex? She finally has the man she always wanted alone in her bedroom. If I were her I would've done it already. Which reminds me, I need to reschedule with Kimberly. I really want to finish what we started. She's just so perfect!

"What do you think, Frank?," Mikey asked.

"I would've fucked him already," he smirked.

"See!," I yelled.

"I mean, Andy is a really good looking guy. Gorgeous even, so why wouldn't she if she has him to herself with no distractions?," said Frank.

"We're gonna get along just fine," I smirked.

"Because she's smarter than all of us. She's not just gonna give her v-card to someone just because they're good looking," stated Mikey. I guess he's right. She's not a slut like us. I should go wake them up before it gets late.

"I guess. I'ma go wake them up". I got up and made my way up stairs. I wonder how they slept. Did they even sleep? I bet they stayed up all night talking about they're future babies. I slowly opened the door and slipped in. I walked over to the bed. Aw, they're spooning! Aphrodite was faced away from Andy while he had his arm wrapped around her waist. As I got closer I stepped on something. What is this? A towel? I bend down and picked up the towel. That's wierd, why is there blood on the.......wait a......did they.....she wouldn't. Would she?

"They had sex," I said under my breath. I can't believe it! They had sex! She better tell me everything! I quietly jumped in excitement. I can't wait to hear it all. I slowly stepped closer to the bed and bend forward.

"Good morning, love birds!," I yelled. They both jumped up screaming.

"You guys! It's just me, don't worry!," I yelled.

"Dammit Janice! How many times have I told you not to do that!," yelled Aphrodite as she threw a pillow at me. I dodged it and laughed.

"There's not fun in that! Get up before we're late from school".

*Aphrodite's POV*

Damn Janice! One day I'm gonna kill her!

"She does this a lot?," asked Andy.

"Oh yeah". Janice shrugged and walked into my closet.

"Good morning sexy people! Let's get ready to go to hell! I mean school," yelled Mikey as he also walked into my closet along side of Frank.

"Is there like a party happening in there?," laughed Andy. I giggled.

"No. They've stayed over so much that they practically live here. They have some of their clothes in my closet".

"Reminds me, I need get home and change," he said as he started getting dressed.

"No need to sir! I'm sure my clothes fits you," smiled Mikey as he threw a pair of jeans and shirt at Andy. He caught it and looked at it. Mikey gave him a pair of black skinny jeans and a Misfits shirt.

"You like the Misfits?," Andy asked as he put on Mikey shirt.

"Fuck yeah ! Who doesn't?!," he said as he walked back in my closet.

"Well, I guess this will do". I watched him as he put on the jeans. Last night was amazing. Even though we just made out, I loved it! The way he would grab me, touch me, kiss me, even when he squeezed my ass. It got me excited. I bit my lip as I continued to stare at him. Not to mention, he told me he wanted me! Andy Biersack wants me! I hope this last forever.

"Didi," said Andy. Wow, he was serious.

"You're seriously gonna call me that?," I chuckled.

"I told you I was. I like it," he smirked.

"Fine, what is it you need, Bubbles?".

"Do you have any like..extra toothbrushes laying around somewhere?".

"Ah, yes. From the amount of people I bring, my dad bought a box load," I laughed to myself. I got up and walked into my restroom. I bend down and opened the bottom cabinets. Ah, here they are. I got up and walked back out.

"Here you go!," I handed him the container.

"Thanks babe," he kissed my forehead and walked into the restroom. He called me babe! Life is good. I chuckled and walked into my closet.

"You guys done in here?," I asked.

"Yep!," they all yelled in responds.

"Aph, do these jeans make my ass look big?," asked Frank as he examined it in the mirror.

"Yes, why? Is that a bad thing?".

"Nope, they're perfect! I hope Gerard thinks the same thing". Oh Frankie.

"What should I wear today?," I asked as I looked at myself in the mirror.

"Since I hear it was gonna be pretty hot today, I think you should wear...this," said Janice as she handed me my purple spring dress with a black belt in the middle. Not a bad idea.

"For once, I agree with you. I shall wear with my black flats," I said as I grabbed them.

"You're gonna look so beautiful!," Frank jumped in
excitement.

"Since you guys are done, can you get out so I can dress?". One by one they walked out. Just as I was about to close the door, Janice put her foot in the way.

"Once we're alone, you're gonna give me all the dirty details," she winked and closed the door. Dirty details about what? I shrugged it off and removed my clothes. As I put on my dress I noticed a red mark on my neck.

"What's this?". I tried to rub it to remove it, but it didn't work. Is it a hickey? I remembered back to last night and remembered him kissing my neck. I ran my hand down my neck and smiled. I never thought something so simple could cause so much pleasure. I giggled and proceeded to put on my flats. I looked once more in the mirror. Good enough.

"Opps, almost forgot!". I grabbed some black shorts and slipped them on under my dress.

"Don't want anyone seeing my underwear".

*Janice's POV*

"Sup Andy," I said as he walked out the restroom.

"Sup Janice," he smiled.

"Sooo...had fun last night?," I smirked.

"Yeah, it was great".

"I bet".

"What do you mean by that?". He gave me a confused look.

"Oh nothing, just a innocent question". He nodded and looked around.

"Shit," I heard him say under his breath.

"What's wrong?".

"I forgot I had to different colors of shoes on yesterday". I looked around and saw Mikey's all black Converse.

"Here, check if these fit," I handed him the shoes. He sat on the bed and put one on.

"Wow, fits perfectly".

"Great!". Just then Aphrodite walked out."Don't you look sexy?".

*Andy's POV*

I never had Converse before, they look cool. I should buy a pair.

"Don't you look sexy?," I heard Janice say. I look up and couldn't believe my eyes.

"You look so beautiful," I smiled widely. I didn't even think it was possible for her to look more beautiful than she already is. She blushed and grinned.

"Well, gonna brush my teeth, then I'll be right down," she ran into the bathroom.

"Welp, I'll better go downstairs, have fun," she smiled mischievously as she walked out. What's up with her today? I laid back on the bed and I started remembering last night. Never in a million years I thought I would end up being with her again. I guess this whole dare thing was a good thing. Speaking of the dare, I need to end it. For the sake of our future together. What we had last night was the best thing that has happened to me in years. Sure, we just made out, but it was amazing. Her lips were so soft, her skin was so warm, and her moans were such a turn on. Most importantly, the way she handled Gerard was incredible. Hopefully now he understands what I see in her. I sat back up and heard the water turn off. I quietly got up and made my way towards the bathroom door.

*Aphrodite's POV*

Minty clean mouth, check! Hair brushed, check! Mascara and eyeliner, check! Now all I need is lipgloss. I opened the door and jumped back a little as Andy stood there.

"Dammit Andy! You scared me!".

"Sorry," he apologized. He walked in and locked the door behind him. What is he doing? He slowly approached me and pulled me towards him roughly. Oh God, I'm liking this already. He pulled me up and sat me on the sink counter. He grabbed my face and kissed me hungrily. I kissed back as I wrapped my legs around his waist. Oh yes, we're doing this again. He ran his hands up my thighs, under my dress. I pulled him closer, deepening the kiss. We stayed there for about five minutes just sloppily kissing each other. Suddenly there was a knock on the door.

"You done in there yet, Aph," asked Mikey.

"Y..yeah, be right out". We listen quietly till we heard the bedroom door close. We looked at each other and laughed.

"Good thing I decided not to wear lipstick," I smiled as I got off the counter.

"I just want to stay here all day and kiss you're face off!".

"As much as I'd like that, we need to go to school".

"Why?! No one's gonna miss us".

"Andy, we need to go".

"Fine, just for you". I gave him one quick kiss and walked out the restroom.

"Wait, put this on". He handed me his leather jacket.

"It'll make you look badass".

"It's too big".

"So, it will show every one you're mine". I love it when he says that!

"Okay," I smiled as I put on the jacket.

"Perfect! Let's go". ___________________________________

*Cafeteria*

*Gerard's POV*

I can't believe I was actually excited to come to school today. I decided to hand out with Aphrodite's group today. After yesterday I finally realized how cool of a person she really is. I can't believe for so many years we treated her like shit without knowing who she really is. As I made my way to Aphrodite's table, Ronnie called me over to his table. Let's see what he wants.

"Sup Gee!" said Ashley as he have me a high five.

"So we heard what happened last night. What happened to kick Aphrodite's ass no matter what? Except you ended up crying like a little bitch," said Ronnie as he smirked.

"Shut the fuck up, Ronnie. I don't need to hear your shit! What I did happened already and I realized Aph's actually a cool person".

"Aph? You call her Aph now? What the hell happened to you?".

"She opened my eyes and made me realize how stupid I was. I can't believe I wasted my time with you assholes, instead of being with my brother, my true friend. It was nice knowing you". I stuck my middle finger in Ronnie's face and walked away. That felt so good!

"Gerard!," yelled Andy as he waved me over to Aph's table. I smiled and made my way.

*Aphrodite's POV*

"Hey guys, mind if I hang out with you guys today?," asked Gerard.

"You don't need to ask, Gerard. You just come on over," I smiled. He smiled back and sat down next to Janice. This is the first time I see a genuine smile from him.

"Gee Gee baby! I made you lunch!," yelled Frank as he sat on Gerard's lap. He opened he back pack and pulled out a brown paper bag. He made him lunch in my house? Why couldn't he make me lunch?

"It's a turkey sandwich, potato chips, water, and coffee. She didn't have any soda or anything. Enjoy!".

"We have chips?," I asked in disbelief.

"Uh, thanks. I love coffee," Gerard smiled nervously. They look so cute together.

"I know. Andy told me". Gerard a questionable look to Andy.

"He wanted to know everything about you," Andy smirked.

"Why didn't you make yourself a sandwich?," I asked.

"I'm a vegetarian," he smiled with pride.

"Ah, why didn't you make me a sandwich?," I joked.

"I'm Gerard's sandwich maker, not yours," he stuck out his tongue.

"Wow, this is really good," grinned Gerard.

"I made it with love," he said as he kissed Gerard's cheek. Gerard just smiled and blushed a bit.

*Janice's POV*

What hasn't she told me?! I'm her best friend and she doesn't wanna tell me about her first time?! That's it!

"Aph, can I talk to you?," I asked.

"Sure," she smiled. I made my way to the corner of the wall.

"What do you need to talk about?".

"Why don't you wanna tell me?".

"Tell you what?".

"You know what I mean! Am I not good enough to know?".

"What are you talking about?!".

"I saw the towel!".

"What about the towel?!".

"It had blood on it!".

"What are you......wait....you think I". She started laughing loudly.

"This isn't funny, Aph!". She continued to laugh as tears formed in her eyes.

"Janice! It's not what you think," she said as she pulled herself together again.

"Then what was it?".

"I cleaned the blood off of Andy last night. He had some on his face".

"You not lying?".

"No, I would never lie to you! You know if I lose my v-card, you'd be the first to know," she smiled.

"Okay, I'm sorry. I shouldn't be assuming things".

"But one thing did happened," she smirked. Really?

"Tell. Me".

"We made out! We were touching each other everywhere, I was on top of him, and he even grabbed my butt. Hard. It was such a turn on!".

"My God! You went to second base!".

"He's such so sexy, sweet, loving. I think I'm in love".

"Aw, my little girls in love!," I laughed as I hugged her.

"So, are we good now?".

"Yup, we're good!".

*Aphrodite's POV*

I can't believe she thought I had sex with Andy. I would've love to, but I'm too nervous.

"Hey, what did you two talked about?," asked Andy as he sat me on his lap.

"She thought we had sex," I whispered in his ear. He laughed and blushed.

"Why would she think that?".

"She thought the towel I used to clean you was blood from my...panini".

"Oh God!," he laughed even louder. I looked around and saw Scout staring at us. She rolled her eyes and looked away. What's her problem? Oh right, she was Andy's girlfriends.

"Hey Andy".

"Hmm".

"Why did you and Scout break up?".

*Andy's POV*

Shit! I forgot about Scout! I never broke up with her. I was so caught up with Aph I....dammit! I looked over at Scout and she nudged her head towards the door as she walked out.

"Um, I gotta go to the bathroom really quick".

"Okay, hurry back!," smiled Aphrodite. She stood up and went over to Janice. I quickly made my way out the door. Scout stood there, leaning on the lockers.

"What are you doing?," she asked angrily.

"What do you mean?".

"You are spending all your time with her! I never get to see you anymore. The last time we saw each other we had sex and not only that, you look at her and hold her in ways you never did to me! I want you to end this dare!".

"What?".

"I want you to end this dare! I don't like you being with her! You belong with me and only me!".

"Well guess what Scout, you are no one to tell me what to do! I'm not your property". She came closer and wrapped her arms around my neck.

"I love you, Andy and I don't wanna lose you".

"Scout please..".

"I love you, Andy!".

"Scout stop...".

"I love you!".

"I don't!". She unwrapped her arms and looked at me with widen eyes as tears started to form.

"You don't love me?".

"Now that I realize, I never did and I know for a fact you don't love me. We just wanted each other for sex and I don't what that anymore".

"You do you mean by that?". She crossed her arms.

"We're done".

"What?," she asked in disbelief.

"Me and you. We're done".

"You can't do that! We belong together!".

"No we don't!".

"This is all her fault!".

"Who?".

"That bitch! That good for nothing whore!".

"Watch your fucking mouth, Scout! Don't you talk about her that way".

"Why? It's not like you're actually going out with her. This is all a lie, Andy and the day she finds out, she'll never want to see you again. She will never want to see you, talk to you, or even be around you!".

"What makes you think she'll find out?".

"I'm gonna tell her and once I do I'm gonna have the pleasure of watching her fall. I'ma watch her precious little heart break and it's all gonna be your fault". She smiled.

"Scout, don't do this".

"Oh, I'm going to tell her, but when you least expect it. Not today, not tomorrow, but soon". And with that she walked away. She's right. If Aphrodite ever finds out she was apart of a dare, she'll never talk to me again. What do I do? I don't want to cause her pain anymore and I don't wanna hurt her. She's everything to me. She means the world to me.......I love her.

Notes