I Dare You

"Good morning," someone whispered in my ear. I smiled, stretched and yawned. I opened my eyes, expected to see Andy, but instead I saw Janice laying next to me. I yelled and jump, which in result, made me fall of the bed.

"Ow!," I yelled in pain. I heard Janice laughing in the background.

"What the hell, Janice?".

"What?! I didn't do anything!," she yelled as she laughed harder.

"Why would you do that?!". I got up and rubbed my ass. It hurts!

"You were expecting Andy?," she sang as she winked. I giggled and threw a pillow at her.

"Obviously! Where is he?". "He's downstairs talking to Mikey, Frank, and Jayy".

"Ah, what time is it?". I scratched my head and yawned again.

"Nine twenty-seven". What?!

"We're late for school!," I yelled as I ran inside my closet. I quickly dressed in random clothes and ran in the bathroom.

"What's the hurry?," asked Janice as she walked in the bathroom.

"We're late for school!," I yelled as I brushed my teeth.

"There's no school today". I stopped dead in my tracks and slowly turned my head towards her.

"What?".

"Yeah, some teacher thingy thing," she waved her hand. I released a big sigh and leaned back in the counter.

"Oh, thank God".

"What happened?," asked Andy as he popped his head in.

"Ms. Sexually Frustrated over here thought there was school today. She went psycho and started getting ready," Janice smirked. Andy laughed and walked over to me, kissing my forehead.

"And she scared me! I fell and hurt my ass," I pouted.

"Janice, don't do that! You're gonna ruin them," said Andy as he massage my ass. I laughed and smacked his hand away.

"Come on! Let's go downstairs, before Mikey and Jayy start having sex on your couch and I have a feeling Frank is gonna join," said Janice as she lead the way. We all ran downstairs to Mikey, Jayy, Frank....and Gerard?

"Hey man! What you doing here?," asked Andy as he walked over to Gerard and did some form of hand shake.

"Just came to chill with you guy, hope you don't mind," Gerard smiled.

"Not at all!," I smiled back. We all sat on the couch. Me on Andy, Frank on Gerard, Jayy on Mikey, and Janice alone as usual.

"I need Kimberly," she pouted angrily and crossed her arms. We laughed and pointed at her.

"Oh shut it, you assholes!," she yelled.

"No need to wait any longer". We all turned our heads towards the kitchen door and saw Kimberly.

"How do you guys get in my house?," I asked in confusion.

"Kimi, baby!," yelled Janice as she ran towards her. She lifted her up and spun her around. Kimberly giggled and kissed her.

"Eww!," we all exclaimed. She gave us the finger as she continued to kiss her. Once they finished, they sat down, Kim on top of Janice.

"Anyways, did you two have sex?". Fuckin' Janice.

"What?! You two had sex!," said Frank.

"What?! No," I yelled in defense.

"Sure, but when you're ready to tell me, I'll be right here," she smirked.

"Andy, can I talk to you?," asked Gerard as he lifted Frank off of him. Andy nodded and walked into the kitchen. Weird.

"Hey you guys! Guess what?," I whispered.

"You two did have sex?!," Janice whispered back.

"No! Stop thinking about that!".

"Sorry".

"I have my moms number". They all gasped.

"Wait, why are we gasping?," asked Frank.

"Aphrodite hasn't seen her mom in years. How did you get it?," asked Jayy.

"Last night I had dinner at Andy's house and turns out, my mom has been talking to his mom this entire time! Pretending she still lives here, saying she got a good job that requires a lot of flying".

"What?! That bitch!," said Janice as she balled her fist. I glared at her. "Sorry".

"Anyways, I called her last night," they gasped again," and it was her!".

"What'd she say?," asked Mikey.

"She recognized my voice, I guess, because she said my name". They gasped again. "Oh, stop gasping!".

"I'ma go get a drink," said Kim as she got up.

"Get me some popcorn! This is good," said Frank.

*Andy's POV*

"Andy, can I talk to you?," asked Gerard as he got up. I nodded and we made our way to the kitchen.

"What you wanna talk about?," I asked.

"Did you have sex with her?," he asked, worried.

"No, why?".

"The dare, Andy". Right as that was leaving my memory, he had to bring it back up.

"I know, Gerard," I groaned.

"Have you told her?".

"No".

"Why not?!".

"Cause it's not that easy, Gerard. I fuckin' feel in love with here, dude! I love her and the last thing I wanna do it hurt her". Gerard pushed his hair back in frustration.

"This is bad".

"Don't you think I know that?".

"Well...you still need to tell her Andy".

"Tell her what?! Hey, so I was dared to have sex with you and leave you right after! I can't do it!".

"You have to! The longer you wait, the worst it'll get and the bigger chance of her to never forgive you". I let out a sigh and leaned back.

"Do you have any idea how much that's gonna hurt no only her, but me?".

"I understand, but you can't keep it from her forever. You're giving Ronnie the chance to tell her himself and he's not gonna say it in the nice possible way". He's right. Every since I stopped hanging out with, he does nothing, but glare at me angrily. Every time I meet his eyes he just....stares and smirks.

"You're right, but when?".

"When the time is right," he placed his hand on my shoulder and gave me a warm smile.

"Yo, dudes! Come here!," yelled Janice from the living room.

*Kimberly's POV*

"I'ma go get something to drink," I said as I got off of Janice's lap.

"Get me some popcorn! This is good," said Frank. I chuckled as I made my way towards the kitchen. Right as I was about to step in, I overheard Gerard and Andy talking.

"Tell her what? Hey, so I was dared to have sex with you and leave you right after! I can't do!," I heard Andy say. I gasped and put my hand over my mouth.

"You have to! The longer you wait, the worst it'll get and the bigger chance of her to never forgive you," said Gerard. I slowly walked backwards as I bumped into the door frame, leading to the living room.

This whole thing, between him and Aphrodite, is just a game? He's just gonna get what he wants and leave her! She's gonna be so devastated! I can't him hurt her! I have to tell her!

You can't.

And why not?

Look at how happy she is, don't ruin that for her.

Oh, shut up, brain! I need to tell her. He's gotta tell her himself.

Why?

It'll hurt her more to hear it from you than from him. I sighed and leaned my head back. Ugh! What do I do? I shook my head and put a smile on my face as I walked back in the room.

"Where's my popcorn?," pouted Frank.

"Uh, I couldn't find it," I sat on Janice lap again.

"So, what do you want us to do?," asked Mikey.

"I need you guys to get Andy away for a while. Say you guys are gonna get something at the store and take your time. That way I can have a chance to try and talk to her," said Aph.

"Okay, got it! Yo, dudes! Come here!," yelled Janice. I glared at Andy and Gerard they made their way into the living room. You assholes!

"What's up?," asked Andy.

"We need to go buy some stuff at the store and we need all the men we can get," said Janice.

"Uh, yeah sure. You coming Didi," he smirked. Aphrodite blushed. You liar!

"Nah, I'm just gonna stay here. I have some things to handle," she smiled. Don't fall for it girl!

"Then I'll stay here with you".

"Nonononono," said Jayy as he grabbed Andy by the arm," we need you".

"But..".

"It''s fine, you go".

"...Okay". He gave her a kiss and left out the door.

"Well let's go Kimi," said Janice. I shook my head and smiled.

"Let's".

*Aphrodite POV*

Once they all left I ran up to my room and to my closet. Where did I throw my phone? Where did I throw my phone. After searching for about five minutes I finally found it inside one of my shoes. How did it get in there? I grabbed the phone and ran back down stairs and sat on the couch.

"Well, this is it," I took a deep breath and unlocked my phone

"No backing out, I need to hear what she has to say". I went to my call logs and called the number back from last night. This is it! The phone rang a few times before someone finally answered.

"Hello?," she asked. It's so nice to hear her voice again. say something! I inhaled deeply again.

"Mom?".

"Aphrodite? Is it you?".

"Yes".

"Oh honey! It's been so long! H...How did you get my number?".

"That's least important right now. I need you to tell me why".

"Why what?".

"Why did you leave?".

"Honey I..".

"Please don't call me that. Dad calls me that". I heard her sigh.

"Okay".

"But why did you leave?".

"Ho...Aphrodite, it's something you'll never understand".

"Is it, because he has more money?".

"Excuse me?".

"You know who I'm talking about. The man you meet at the bar".

"Did Amy tell you that?". Shit. Play it off.

"Who's Amy?".

"Don't play games with me".

"I'm not. Who is she?".

"Andrew's mom?".

"Andrew....Andrew....ah, I see. I haven't talked to him since you left mom".

'Then how do you know?".

"After years you find out a few things and like I said it's not important".

"What do you want?". Wow.

"I want you to tell me the truth on why you left".

"You already know, so why should I..".

"Mom please! Do you have any idea how much I needed you?! You can at least do this one thing for me". There was silence on the other side of the phone. I sighed and lowered my head.

"If you're gonna man up and tell me the truth, meet me at the mall you use to take me shopping to tomorrow at three by the food court. Then there you can share your side of the story and help me understand". I quickly hung up before she said anything else.

"Instead of being happy to hear from me, she questions me on my information. What a great person," I said to myself as a tear ran down my cheek. I just hope she meets me tomorrow.

Notes

Hey guys! Hope you liked this chapter and are excited for the next one cause I have some drama planned. I wanted to know if you guys would like a chapter dedicated to only Janice, Kimberly, Frank, Gerard, Mikey, and Jayy? Please let me know and if any of you are Motionless In White fans, please check out my other story, So Wrong Yet So Right. Here's the link: http://www.motionlessinwhitefanfiction.com/Story/54213/So-Wrong-Yet-So-Right/ it will mean a lot :)
Anyways, love you guys, thanks for the comments, subscriptions, votes, and views, it really means a lot ❤ and let me know about what you think of that idea :)

XOXO
-K