I hear the door open behind me, then close. Heavy footsteps make their way over to where I am, then two arms engulf me into a hug. "Why did you kiss me?" I whisper. Andy sighs, "because I thought it would be fine since no one exactly counts a peck as a kiss."
"I asked you not to kiss me." Andy's fingers raise up my chin, his blue eyes boring into mine, "I'm sorry. I shouldn't have done that."
"Ya. Now I can't say that I had my first kiss with someone who I wanted it to be with." I grumble, Andy's expression falls, I know he likes me. I can read emotions well. "Hey, Indiana I'm really sorry. I just got caught up in the part we were playing. We are still friends right?" The hopeful gleam in his eye makes me feel bad about saying no, "yes."
"Should we forget that happened then?"
"Andy, I can't forget that- that was my first kiss." I sigh. He nods, "it was better than mine, a lot of teeth."
"What?"
"I bet you would be a great kisser if we actually had kissed and not just pecked." He mumbles, his cheeks heating up slightly. His bad attempt at recovery ends up being stammered, "I think we should go either explain to them what happened or keep playing the parts of boyfriend and girlfriend."
"Lets keep doing it. Did you see the looks on their faces?" I exclaim, taking Andy's hand to stand up, he chuckles, "yes! They were just staring at me after you ran away!"
"Did they say anything at all?" He shakes his head, "Shelby and Erica looked slightly pissed though."
"Andy, kiss me when we get back in there, just a peck. Ok?" I say quietly. Andy stops in his tracks at the door, "really? Why?"
"You've already kissed me once, as long as it's just a peck its fine if we are pretending to be a couple." I say nervously, "because pecks don't count.. Right?"
"Ya, they don't." A small smile forms on his lips, which I am suddenly seeming to focus on. "Indiana, we should walk out there and pretend nothing happened. Then when they start the movie again, kiss- I mean peck." I grab his hand again, pulling him down the stairs behind me.
"Can you start the movie again? I've never seen the whole notebook before." I tell them while sitting back on Andy's lap. I have seen it before though. They all snap out of their confusion letting Catherine start the movie again.
"Andy-" I look up into his piercing blue eyes, they make me forget what I was going to say. Andy's smirk disappears as we both understand the intensity of our gaze. I close the gap between our lips before he can, quickly. I simply peck his lips, my hands holding his cheeks, keeping our lips pressed together for a few moments. I pull away, but am quickly pulled into another kiss, Andy's hands are soft against my cheeks as he cups then both.

I don't want to pull away this time... What did I just think?

I don't pull away, neither does he. Our lips just pressed together into a simple peck, my legs strung across his lap, my arms around his neck. When we both pull away, our eye contact is renewed.
That's when I realize... I have a crush on Andy. And he likes me as well. I just kissed him!
"Indiana?" Catherine's voice startles us out of our trance. I turn to see that the tv was turned off and all five girls are staring at us again. "Are you..?"
"Uh..." I can't say yes. Then she would believe me. I can't say no because that would ruin what we've done. "Indiana, my mom wants me home." Andy says quietly, breaking the awkward blanket that has hushed the room. "I'll go with you to get your bag." I sigh, standing up. Andy follows me solemnly upstairs, "I'm sorry." He mumbles once we are in the doorway of my room.
"Don't be." I mumble, "I kissed you." His eyes widen as I say this. He's probably thinking, 'oh shit.'
"Indiana, I-" he sighs, "Nevermind. I have to go. I'll see you tomorrow at school." I trail him down the stairs, out the front door, to his car. Before he gets in I tap his shoulder, Andy opens his mouth to speak but I quickly place my lips on his for a moment. "Bye."
He stands there, seemingly speechless as I turn on my heels and rush inside. "Catherine, I'm going to bed. I'll see you in the morning!" I am about to turn in my room when rushing footsteps come up the stairs, "no, no, no.." Catherine grabs my hand, pulling me back downstairs, she sits me back in the chair Andy and I were in before. "What the hell was that?" I close my eyes, take a deep breath, "what was what?" She sits back where the four others are watching me, "you kissed him. He kissed you."
"So, it was just a peck. They don't count." I mumble nonchalantly, "why do you care anyways?"
"Because you're my sister and you just had your first kiss with Andy six!" She exclaims, "he is so hot indie girl!"
"So hot." Shelby repeats to herself sadly.
"I don't feel comfortable." I mumble.
"Take advantage of having Andy while you do. Guys are pricks." Chloe says quietly.
"As i said before, I'm going to bed. G'night Catherine." I am about to walk away when she grabs my shoulder. "No, we are helping you pick out what to wear for tomorrow. He obviously likes you so you need to step it up and impress the guy."
"I'm not dressing like you guys." I sigh. My sister winks, "I think I know what my sister likes to wear."
"Fine, go pick out whatever you want from my closet." I sigh, waving my hand in a dismissal. She rolls her eyes and pulls me along by the hand to my room, the four friends trailing behind her. As soon as they open my closet clothes begin to be thrown around, held up, and made faces at. They finally settle on an outfit after half an hour. I force them to put all my clothes back when they were done.
"Bye." I groan as they finally file out of my door so I can just sleep. The tiredness is there but my mind is alert.
Andy.
He is definitely more than a friend now that I've kissed him, and I think I like him in that way as well. Andy obviously likes me as well, his body language and blatant flirting show it.
Maybe we should date? I doubt it..

Notes

I've been writing so much on multiple stories that I'm forgetting to update. I'm trying to be better about it...
Thanks for reading! And to everyone who has commented, rated, or subscribed!
-C